PRINATBALE VERSION HERE

Introduction

In Europe alone, subscription models and paid memberships account for EUR 350 billion, dominated by information and technology (think Microsoft or Adobe software), as well as media and content (Netflix obviously). Consumer goods ‘only’ represent 15% of the total business.

According to a McKinsey study, consumers attached to paid membership programmes are 60% more likely to spend, compared with only 30% for free loyalty programs. Purchases are said to be more frequent and average baskets bigger, transforming paying members to extremely valuable customers. While the footprint of paid loyalty programmes still remains small, it has expanded with Covid. Why? Firstly, with stores closed, subscription services offered a convenient way to keep needed products on hand. But that’s not the only reason as offering the usual discounts and free delivery through a basic 3-level (bronze, silver, gold) free membership feels somehow basic to the consumers who find other ways to access such table-stake perks anyway.

With the war in Ukraine and Covid locking down a part of China, inflation is skyrocketing. As a result, consumers are forced to lower their discretionary spending, and they tend to discontinue their subscriptions whether it’s for Netflix or goods.

But still, brands and retailers need to pimp their loyalty programmes, and paid membership remains an option to consider for funding more interesting and exclusive perks that customers agree to pay for as soon as programmes match their expectations. Firstly, customers want high benefits that balances out or exceeds the fee amounts. Secondly, they want benefits that can be used immediately and as frequently as possible. Finally, with everything else in retail right now, they want experiences. Illustrating such expectations and following up with last year’s Exclusive about subscription retail, the IADS gathered the latest initiatives in paid membership.

Higher benefits

Pret A Manger has a subscription service and it’s not new: customers pay a EUR 20 fee per month and can benefit from up to 5 beverages per day. Whereas it’s unlikely that all subscribers will extensively use their 5 beverages every day, the perks of the programme are way higher than the fees. It shows that attracting new members comes with strong benefits clearly outweighing fees. In fact, consumers expect to receive at least a 150% return in perks when compared to the subscription fee. As a result, brands and retailers considering a paid program must make their value extremely visible.

In US pharmacy retail, the CVS CarePass programme charges a USD 5 monthly fee and offers its members 20% off on all CVS Health brand products in addition to services like free shipping and a 24/7 pharmacy helpline. Knowing the high price point of drugs in the US, the discount rate is really appealing compared to the reasonable monthly fee.

Some recent initiatives like renting fashion are a great push to the subscription business. In the luxury department store area, the Japanese group owning Daimaru-Matsuzakaya launched in March 2021 a new subscription-based rental service to try to escape the traditional inventory-based business model. The new service allows customers to rent up to 3 high-end women’s clothing items from brands such as Marni or See by Chloé, for a monthly fee of approximately USD 103. Fees are rather low when compared to the cost of 3 items from premium or luxury brands. While acquiring more loyal customers, the department store hopes to achieve a USD 55 million turnover by 2026 thanks to a projected 30,000 customer base.

Whereas it’s too soon to know if such a business can be profitable in itself, it will be interesting to check if the Financial Times is right: in an article from September 2021, they argue that the subscription model works best for higher priced-items. Anyway, it seems like a win-win deal: for the department store, it’s about increasing customer loyalty while reducing inventory. On the customer’s side, it represents a new access to luxury products, and an answer to sustainability concerns.

Now and always

Customers want to use their membership perks immediately upon sign-up, and very frequently: 50% of cancellations occur within the first year of membership. In that case, the main reason is that they are not using the benefits enough to justify the membership fees.

Walmart launched a membership programme in September 2020 primarily designed to compete with Amazon, the ultimate champion when it comes to immediacy and recurrent usage. Walmart+ members pay a USD 98 annual fee and are offered perks like an app allowing them to skip the checkout line, unlimited free deliveries with no minimum, member-only game console releases, up to 85% off on prescription drugs, discounts on gas, and special promotions and events. Also, at a time when customers were afraid of potential product shortages, they have enjoyed a true competitive advantage: early access to the 2021 Black Friday deals. Now accounting for 32 million members, Walmart+ can boast about amazing statistics: Cowen analysts estimate 12 million US households have a Walmart+ membership and 69.6% use it at least once a week. Members currently account for about 13% to 14% of the total Walmart.com business.

On the brand side, On Running sports shoes released a running shoe monthly subscription in April 2021. Dedicated to serious and frequent runners, they pay GBP 25 per month to subscribe (rent) their pair. When the shoes are worn-out, the customer can stop the subscription or request a new pair. Once it arrives, customer can send their old shoes back to On Running, who takes care of recycling, an additional perk answering customers’ environmental concerns.

In fashion, Ralph Lauren launched a rental subscription service in March 2021, a first for a luxury brand. The service aims to be a new channel for customers to engage with the brand. Starting at USD 125 per month, subscribers can access a constantly renewed range of clothing. Members curate their own online closet before receiving their shipment. Once they are done with the clothes, they can choose to either send them back and have them replaced by new styles or purchase them at exclusive member prices. On top of creating loyalty, the ‘Lauren Look’ is also a great opportunity to generate direct customer feedback and gain a better understanding of their expectations. As for On Running, the initiative also answers the growing consumer concerns about overconsumption.

Still, offering discounts remains a mandatory perk. In that perspective, Vasquiat is an interesting alternative free membership model when it comes to immediate discounts. Founded by Spanish influencer Blanca Miro, Vasquiat is defining itself as “the marketplace for discovering the most exciting emerging brands in the world.” What’s more important is that they “disrupt the traditional model by creating a new category: the discounted pre-order.” Vasquiat’s members can pre-order styles from the next season's collections at up to 40% off. The sooner they buy, the less they pay, reversing the usual end-of-season discount model. Then, the closer the collections are to their official release date, the smaller the discount is, until eventually reaching the full retail price.

Experience and emotion

Even though they remain table-stake perks, free delivery and discounts are not enough to lure and retain customers for paid membership programmes. Consumers are looking for differentiation. In that sense, they are expecting exclusive offerings, personalized and more emotional experiences, or member-only content.

In that perspective, Volvo launched a new car dealership concept inspired by clubhouses in 2021. Opening first in Amsterdam (now available in 6 other cities across Northern Europe), Lynk & Co is more than just a car dealership. The club house is the promotional face for a hybrid SUV that members can rent starting at EUR 500 per month (including insurance and maintenance service). The brand's strategy is simple: focus on car sharing through a subscription system (which is especially relevant in a city like Amsterdam where people don’t need a car on a full-time basis), and attract new customers through the services offered by the clubhouse. It includes a lounge area with a bar to host DJ sets, exhibitions, as well as workshops, film screenings, etc… These events are of course reserved to members who feel nurtured with the emotion of being part of an exclusive club.

In an attempt to compete with Amazon, Best Buy launched a USD 199.99 membership programme in April 2021, designed to basically offer great customer service. Among various perks (such as free 2-day deliveries, up to 24 months of product protection, dedicated phone teams, extended 60-day return and exchange window), the 24/7/365 tech support and product installation in particular offer a security sentiment and a safe product experience to members. The membership, called ‘Totaltech’, also includes ‘My Best Buy’ programme perks (including reward points and exclusive deals).

Food is highly about experience and emotion. Shinsegae department store in Korea came up with an interesting initiative: a fresh fruit subscription service which has proved very popular since its inception in April 2021. As part of the “VIP Gold” loyalty program, customers can subscribe to the service for a monthly fee of approximately USD 194 and they have a selection of seasonal fruits delivered to their door on a weekly basis. Tips on how to store and eat the fruits are also included as part of the package. This new service follows up the launch of a bread subscription service: subscribers can pick up bread in store every day for a monthly fee of approximately USD 42. Shinsegae’s goal is obvious and clear: “attract people to the store, which could lead to the purchase of other products.”

When it comes to paid memberships, the wholesale club model in groceries is also a true lever to loyalty. But it can do more: it can help create a sense of belonging, which will give customers more reasons to visit and push them to significantly increase their purchases. It’s the case with Store X supermarkets (a division of Alibaba in China). With its USD 40 yearly membership, Store X targets a group of young, affluent, digitally savvy shoppers expecting to be treated differently, and willing to spend more for better services and shopping experiences. The first Store X opened in Shanghai at the end of 2020 and became profitable within two months.

Conclusion

So far department stores are sticking to free membership through their loyalty programmes, but they have been revamping them for a few years now. A few months ago, Harvey Nichols in the UK did so with a 5-level ‘classic’ programme where money spent equals reward points. Depending on the level customers will reach, points are converted into benefits revolving around discounts and (more interesting than in other programmes) experiences appealing to many different customer groups: 10% off food & wine, bars & restaurants and beauty & grooming, 15% off fashion vouchers, double points booster, free drink in store, ‘kids eat free’, pamper hamper, birthday gift, dining or beauty school experience, wine or crafty beer box.

While it would be very costly for department stores to design perks and experiences worth a paid membership, the model needs to be considered anyway (and despite the recent subscription model setbacks), especially if focusing on big spenders that are not really impacted by inflation and who are always expecting additional reasons to visit stores. In that sense, the Soho House business is a model to look at as experiences are part of the equation: at Bloomingdale’s, the Loyalist programme has been redesigned to include a new shopper segment, the ones spending more than USD 15,000 per year. Representing less than 1% of the customer base and mostly women in their forties, these ‘Top Of The List Unlocked’ status members receive elevated benefits such as a 2-star Michelin cooking class at the Baccarat hotel, and even have a private Instagram account to reserve the latest designer styles.

Credits: IADS (Christine Montard)