What: A comprehensive analysis of potential impacts on retail DEI initiatives under a second Trump presidency, highlighting significant policy shifts that could affect industry practices and strategies.

Why it is important: As retailers navigate evolving approaches to diversity and inclusion, understanding potential policy changes is crucial for developing resilient strategies that maintain inclusive practices whilst adapting to new regulatory environments.

The retail industry faces significant changes in DEI implementation under proposed policies for a second Trump presidency. The document outlines plans to eliminate federal DEI programmes and modify enforcement of civil rights laws, particularly impacting how retailers approach workplace policies and supplier diversity initiatives. Key concerns include potential restrictions on DEI training, modifications to discrimination claim processes, and changes to data collection practices. The retail sector has already begun adapting, as evidenced by Walmart's recent strategic pivot to remove explicit DEI language whilst maintaining inclusion practices, and Costco's contrasting approach of firmly defending its DEI programmes. These divergent responses reflect the industry's broader challenge of balancing stakeholder expectations with business performance. The emergence of alternative frameworks, such as FAIR (Fairness, Access, Inclusion, and Representation), suggests retailers are proactively developing new approaches to maintain inclusive practices within evolving regulatory constraints.

IADS Notes: Recent retail industry developments provide context for potential adaptations to new policies. In January 2025, companies like Costco and Apple maintained their DEI commitments despite mounting pressure, while others like Amazon rebranded initiatives as "Inclusive eXperiences and Technology." Walmart's November 2024 strategy of maintaining inclusion practices whilst modifying terminology proved particularly successful, achieving strong market performance. The industry's evolution toward the FAIR framework in early 2025 demonstrates how retailers are preparing for potential policy changes by focusing on measurable outcomes rather than terminology, suggesting a path forward for maintaining inclusive practices in a changing regulatory environment.

What a second presidential term for Donald Trump means for DEI

Seramount's Key Pre-Election Takeaways from the 2024 US Presidential Election Executive Discussion

Charting the Future: DEI Strategies for the Next Four Years