Printable version here

Check out the pictures here

In the last few months, brands have been rushing to open stores on Avenue des Champs-Elysées, hoping to catch a chunk of tourist wallets, especially the ones coming for the 2024 Olympics. Sports brands are no exception and tend to settle in retail spaces in the avenue’s central and lower sections. England-based retailer JD Sports chose another option and opened its new global flagship store in the avenue's upper section (number 118), across the street from the Louis Vuitton flagship store and not far away from Saint Laurent and Cartier. While the store was opened by Brazilian soccer legend and Nike brand ambassador Ronaldinho in April 2024, the group said it will be “continuing its run as the globally recognised king of the high street. JD’s new store offers the brand's latest innovations in digital technology and merchandising and will provide visitors access to all the hottest brands and latest launches.”

JD Sports was founded in 1981 in Bury, in the North West of England, with one shop, John David Sports. The JD group now accounts for more than 3,300 stores worldwide, including 100 in France and 29 JD Sports stores in the Paris region only. In terms of sales, JD Sports claimed in March 2024 to outperform a challenging market with a 4% like-for-like sales growth in the financial year ending 3 February 2024, reaching £10.5 billion, with an 8% organic growth. The profit before tax is expected to reach £915 million.

The retailer’s new flagship store aims to provide an immersive shopping experience to customers and establish itself as one of the sports champions on Champs-Elysées. Who will be the customers visiting the store? What will they find there to differentiate themselves in the crowded area?

Who is the store made for: JD Sports’ young customer base

According to GlobalData UK, JD Sports’ shopper base predominantly comprises male shoppers (61.3%) due to the retailer’s focus on sportswear and lifestyle brands. JD Sports caters to various customers, from sports enthusiasts and sportswear fans to trendy comfort-wear seekers. While they have been able to attract customers from all income groups, JD Sports aims to appeal to a wide range of customers, especially those between the ages of 13 and 35 who are interested in sportswear and streetwear:

• In 2021, Millennial and Gen Z customers made up 51.6% of JD Sports' UK shopper base: 22% were aged between 18 and 24, compared to 11% for its competitor, Sports Direct.
• 38% were from 40 to 59 years old, compared to 41% for Sports Direct customers.

These shares show that JD Sports cracked the code to attract the younger generation: they embrace all the youth culture codes, not just sportswear. With memorable slogans, eye-catching imagery, and partnerships with well-known athletes and celebrities, the brand’s advertising campaigns and social media channels are clearly focusing on this young demographic. During the store visit, the campaign was about ‘Nouvelle Ere’, translated to ‘New Wave’ as a slogan. Through this five-country campaign (UK, Germany, France, Spain and The Netherlands), JD Sports aims to “cultivate emerging talent from key regions” across the brand’s music, sport, community and youth culture pillars.

JD Sports is considered strong both offline and online as it succeeded in becoming an omnichannel retailer that offers a seamless journey to its young customer base, who live with their phones in hand. They show a great understanding of these customers by focusing on trends, backed up by solid data and insights.

What does the store look like: sportswear retail codes and GenZ flare

The store spans 1,500 sqm. The two-storey store window features mannequins and dynamic screens on the first floor, while sneakers wall displays serve as windows visible from the outside on the ground floor. The leading brands sold in the store have their logos on the ground floor windows: Under Armour, The North Face, EA7, On, Puma, Fila, Reebok, Supply & Demand, Ugg, Crocs, Nike, Adidas, Lacoste, New Balance, Asics, Vans, Converse, Juicy Couture, Hoodrich, Columbia, and McKenzie. Not all brands, such as Fred Perry and Tommy Hilfiger, are mentioned on the windows.

Progressing from the entrance to the back of the floor, the ground floor is mainly dedicated to sneakers and articulates as follows:

• Men’s shoes (90% sneakers),
• Women’s shoes (90% sneakers),
• Socks, caps and lifestyle shoes (Birkenstock, Crocs, for example),
• Cash desks and 3 fitting rooms (which were closed at the time of the visit),
• The back of the floor is split into 2 parts: a soccer section (mainly offering team jerseys) and a teen and kids shoe section.

Not surprisingly, the ground floor was crowded with young customers. Quite empty at the time of the visit, the first floor is dedicated to textiles and displays a product offer well-balanced between sports, streetwear and lifestyle clothes:

• For women, the product offer is mainly oriented towards tracksuits, leggings and athleisure wear, balanced with lifestyle brands such as Juicy Couture.
• For men, the offer seems more streetwear-oriented than performance-oriented. It concentrates on daily-wear branded T-shirts, NBA shirts, and bathing suits. For example, The North Face equally offers technical and lifestyle products.
• A similar balanced offer is available for kids and teens.
• 2 fitting rooms and cash desks are also available on this floor.

With various stone and metal types, JD Sports’ store concept is mainly black and grey, the usual colour codes sports retailers use. Touches of yellow are used to catch the customer's attention, especially for direction purposes. The lighting is only made with neon. To cater to the younger generations (at the time of the visit, most store customers were under 20 years old), the concept includes many screens (on the walls and ceilings) promoting the retailer ad campaigns and customer app and the brands they carry. These screens bring additional touches of colour, making the store more appealing. The screens on the ceilings also serve as transitions between sections. The music, pop and rap hits, is loud.

Store services and key features

The sales staff is very young, reflecting the customer base. They are well-trained, smiling, and systematically greet customers from the store entrance and throughout the journey. They wear uniforms: black JD Sports-labelled t-shirts and cargo pants, as well as yellow badge and phone holders, matching the store concept and making them very visible. During the opening month, the store included features like sneaker customisation and clothing embroidery, showcasing JD Sports' commitment to a personalised shopping experience.

All shoe sections are equipped with small TV screens hanging from the ceiling. When customers ask to try a pair of sneakers, sales associates can scan a QR code on products. Depending on the item's availability, the screen informs the sales associate that the required pair is ready to pick up at a specific counter (each item has a picture, reference, store section and requested size). This allows the sales staff to be fully dedicated to customer service instead of going back and forth in the stock room. Despite the many customers in the store, there were not many to try shoes on. It shows the store might be more of an occasion to socialise and browse products for the younger generation than to shop.

BOPIS options are available in the store. On both floors, through a specific ordering kiosk, customers can access the entire product catalogue, order and pay for their order to be delivered to the store of their choice or at home, and retrieve these orders, as well as click-and-collect orders, at the cash desks. At the time of the visit, customers were not using these kiosks.

There are very few fitting rooms in the store. At the time of the visit, only 2 were open, on the first floor, where ready-to-wear is located and where the traffic was relatively low compared to the busy ground floor. This shows again how the young generations use physical stores for experience and inspiration and e-commerce for ordering. Similarly, the cash desks were not busy with customers.

Finally, the soccer section on the ground floor offers a free FIFA Nintendo PS5 game console for small groups.

Sportswear fans know JD Sports’ “Undisputed King of Trainers” slogan. So will Champs-Elysées. The prestigious avenue is getting ready for the Olympics and will be packed with sports brands. Nike has been there since 2020 with its 4,300 sqm House of Innovation. Adidas' flagship store is currently relocated (and should be improved) from the lower to the mid-section of the avenue, with a 2,800 sqm space. On and Salomon are currently under construction. Lululemon opened last year, and Lacoste has a 1,600 sqm flagship store since 2022. How will JD Sports make a difference in this crowded area? JD Sports’ new location is in the more luxury-oriented part of the avenue compared to the other sports brands settled in the lower part with which they compete. As location can make a difference, in good or in bad, JD Sports is the second multi-brand sports retailer on the avenue, after Foot Locker, located in the lower part of the avenue. With a wider choice of sneaker options and a store designed for teens, JD Sports seems poised to attract more younger customers.

.

Credits: IADS (Christine Montard)

What: The Top 100 NRF ranking shows an overall stabilisation

Why it is important: Convenience, diversification, digitalization are the common traits of the post-pandemic winners.

The National Retail Federation, analyzed by Kantar, identifies a "big trend" in its Top 100 Retailers list: the stabilization of pandemic-era spending patterns. In the 2023 rankings, the top 20 retailers remained mostly unchanged, with slight shifts such as CVS and Target swapping positions, demonstrating the resilience and financial muscle of these leading companies. Walmart continues to dominate with USD 533 billion in U.S. sales, while even the 20th ranked 7-Eleven garnered USD 27.88 billion. Only five of the top 20 experienced minimal losses.

The top performers continue to leverage mergers and acquisitions for growth. For instance, Overstock.com saw a dramatic 135.1% sales increase after acquiring Bed Bath & Beyond's online operations, marking the highest growth rate on the list. Meanwhile, Dick’s Sporting Goods and Walmart also reported growth, the latter even after divesting several subsidiaries.

Significant movements in the grocery sector include the Kroger and Albertsons merger still pending legal approval, with both companies experiencing modest sales increases. Other grocers like Publix and H.E. Butt Grocery showed notable growth, reflecting strong sector performance despite rising food costs, which David Marcotte of Kantar does not attribute solely to inflation.

On a broader scale, the retail landscape shows signs of post-pandemic adaptation, with shifts towards more convenience and digital integration. Marcotte highlights that strategic adjustments are crucial as consumer behaviors evolve, particularly in sectors like convenience stores and consumer electronics, which are experiencing cyclical challenges. Sprouts Farmers Market and Harbor Freight Tools exemplify aggressive expansion strategies, significantly increasing their store counts.

The top three retailers—Walmart, Amazon, and Costco—demonstrate strategic consistency and diversification, including Walmart's push into financial services and Amazon's continued investment in innovative projects. These companies set benchmarks for navigating retail dynamics effectively, emphasizing the importance of adaptation and strategic planning in maintaining industry leadership.

NRF releases its annual top 100 ranking

What: Tracking technology in the wellness industry is evolving and may soon significantly impact the beauty industry by providing hyper-personalized skincare and beauty products based on biometric data.

Why It Is Important: As consumers increasingly seek scientifically supported wellness routines, the beauty industry can leverage biometric tracking to offer personalized products, thus enhancing customer satisfaction and potentially driving sales. However, it also raises concerns about data privacy, mental health implications, and the potential for obsessive health monitoring.

The wellness industry, valued at over a trillion dollars, is rapidly evolving with a focus on biometric tracking technologies that provide real-time data on various health parameters. This shift is likely to influence the beauty industry, enabling brands to offer personalized skincare and beauty products based on individual biometric data. Companies like Apple, Oura, and Garmin are leading this trend, making wellness tracking devices popular. Experts predict that beauty products will soon be tailored based on data from menstrual cycles, gut and skin microbiomes, and sleep patterns. However, concerns about data privacy, mental health, and the potential for obsessive monitoring need to be addressed. Brands must adopt holistic approaches and robust data protection measures to ensure consumer trust and well-being. The integration of wellness tracking in beauty promises a more personalized and effective approach to skincare and beauty routines.

Tracking has reshaped the wellness industry. Are beauty brands next?

What: 87% of companies are deploying AI project for testing purpose

Why it is important: Only 36% are clear about where this could lead and pilot according to a vision

The widespread adoption of AI across industries is evident with 87% of companies now piloting or deploying generative AI, and significant investments averaging $5 million annually, escalating up to $18 million for larger enterprises. Despite the quick proliferation of AI, challenges in implementation that align with profit generation remain prevalent. Yet, companies report a satisfactory outcome in 75% of AI use cases, a slight decline from previous records but still indicative of sustained positive performance without falling into the typical hype cycle downturns.

However, only 36% of firms have a strong vision for AI utilization, with technology companies showing greater readiness and superior outcomes compared to their non-tech counterparts. There is a noted increase in concerns about technological readiness, with a 10% rise in firms citing inadequate tech platforms as a major barrier to faster AI adoption, overtaking issues like lack of expertise and data readiness.

AI survey: according to Bain, AI is everywhere but priorities are shifting

What: While AI takes much of the light, retail media is still a paer of the business that retailers should look at.

Why it is important: Macy’s generated 160m$ of revenue from scratch in just 2 years.

Retail media is rapidly growing, with the UK market estimated at £4 billion in 2024. Successful implementation requires the right technology, dedicated teams, and board alignment.

Brands emphasize collaboration between commercial and marketing teams. PepsiCo's full-funnel approach integrating in-store and digital activations showed 65% higher revenue lifts.

Retail media could more than double grocery retailers' margins from 1.7% to 4.3% long-term. In-store opportunities are emerging through smart carts, screens, and other technologies to capture data and enable targeted messaging.

Challenges remain around data standardization and attribution. Brands seek partnerships with retailers to influence capabilities.

Long-term, major retailers could potentially pivot to become media/tech companies, using retail primarily as a data source. However, this carries risks of shifting focus away from serving shoppers.

Overall, retail media offers significant margin potential, especially in grocery, but requires overcoming obstacles in standardization and in-store implementation.

Coresight: a Retail Media Report

What: McKinsey encourages companies to review the way they assess their new talents’ value

Why it is important: In a world where flexibility is key, recruiters need to based their judgement on skills and ability to evolve, rather than labels or diplomas.

Labor markets in advanced economies have been tightening continuously since 2010, further exacerbated by demographic shifts like aging populations and decelerating birth rates. Despite some loosening from their 2022 peaks, these labor markets are tighter than any point in the last two decades, indicating a structural, rather than pandemic-induced, trend. As populations age and workforce growth slows, without substantial increases in labor productivity or workforce expansion through higher participation rates and immigration, these economies could struggle to achieve significant economic growth.

Job vacancies have increased particularly in sectors with traditionally low or stagnant productivity, such as healthcare, hospitality, and construction. This uneven distribution implies that without strategic interventions, labor shortages will persist in sectors unable to enhance productivity. The economic impact is considerable, with GDP potentially 0.5% to 1.5% higher in 2023 had labor demands been met. Strategies for addressing these challenges include enhancing productivity through technology, retraining workers, and expanding the labor pool through immigration and increased participation, especially among groups like women and older workers.

McKinsey: for your future hires, judge on skills, not diplomas

What: McKinsey reviews the state of tech in 2024 and its various deployments in several industries

Why it is important: companies invest more in applied AI than in generative AI so far.

The McKinsey Technology Trends Outlook 2024 identifies sustained growth and strategic shifts in the technology sector despite economic headwinds. The report focuses on 15 technology trends, highlighting the expansive rise of generative AI (gen AI) and electrification & renewables as leaders in innovation, investment, and industry application.

Gen AI, in particular, has seen a 700% increase in interest from 2022 to 2023, with large language models (LLMs) expanding their 'context windows' from 100,000 to two million tokens, significantly enhancing their complexity and utility across various data modalities. This surge in capability has driven a similar leap in investments and has seen these technologies being incorporated into enterprise applications ranging from customer service to advanced computing systems.

On the other hand, electrification and renewables continue to attract attention and funding, outpacing other technologies in investments and interest scores, underscoring their importance in the current economic landscape driven by decarbonization efforts and energy security needs.

Despite a downturn in technology equity investments in 2023, falling by 30-40% to around $570 billion, the sector's innovation pace has not slowed, particularly within AI and machine learning domains. The report notes a significant talent demand across the technological landscape, with a notable skills gap persisting despite an overall 8% increase in job postings from 2021 to 2023.

The 2024 McKinsey Tech report

Printable version here

The rise of department stores in the mid-19th century marked the beginning of a commercial revolution that shaped retail and consumer culture as we know it. The world's first department store, Au Bon Marché, founded by Aristide Boucicaut in 1852, introduced groundbreaking commercial innovations and created a capitalist business model that birthed unique and effective marketing techniques still commonly used by retailers today.

The IADS had the opportunity to visit the “Birth of Department Stores” exhibit on display from the 10th of April to the 13th of October 2024 at the Musée des Arts Décoratifs in Paris. The exhibition's second part (IADS is a partner) will be presented at the Cité de l'Architecture et du Patrimoine from November 2024 to April 2025. It will place the emergence of department stores in a broader context, looking at the history of these institutions over time and in an international context.

Such excitement around the topic of department stores called for a piece on their history, reminding us why we love this model so much. From the seven hundred pieces on display, ranging from posters to clothing and toys to furniture, the exhibit allows visitors to understand the evolution of commerce and department stores from 1852 onwards. The long history of department stores underscores their lasting impact on both the commercial landscape and societal norms, prompting reflection on future innovations that will define the next era of retail.

We connect in the below piece the most recent initiatives spotted around the planet to their origins, and try to see if modern department stores remain true to their original groundbreaking role.

Department Stores started a commercial revolution

The exhibit outlines the rise of department stores in Paris, France, where the first-ever department store was born, becoming the new template of modernity and consumerism in the 19th century.

The rise of department stores in the mid-19th century started a commercial revolution that fundamentally transformed retail and consumer culture. Au Bon Marché’s Aristide Boucicaut laid the foundations of modern commerce with major commercial innovations like the invention of sales, fixed prices and seasonal exhibitions, children as a new commercial segment, and even mail-order sales.

Each of these innovations answered a specific question. Seasonal sales solved the question of extra inventory and were an occasion to attract less affluent customers willing to shop at Le Bon Marché despite limited means. Exhibitions helped maintain customer interest throughout the year and reduced slow periods. By organising events for products like household linens and fashion accessories, department stores could sustain a steady flow of customers. The use of free advertising calendars given to customers and posters by prominent illustrators further enhanced the appeal and visibility of the store, creating a culture of regular shopping events that encouraged consumerism.

Including children's sections in department stores marked a significant shift in retail strategy. As societal views on childhood evolved, children became a new commercial target and an additional way to attract female customers. Stores began offering a variety of children's clothing and toys, reflecting the growing importance of children in the family unit. Since then, department stores always maintained kidswear and toy sections, sometimes making them a strength in their business, as is the case at Manor, especially with toys. Despite ongoing challenges with kids-related products, department stores continue to find ways to represent this segment, showing the importance of an extensive product offer catering to their primary customers, women. Department stores show great agility in mitigating the impact of kids' product slowdown. For example, in May 2024, Galeries Lafayette Haussmann partnered with US famous retailer FAO Schwarz: the company took over the existing toys department to create a 620 sq. meter new toy area featuring iconic elements like toy soldiers and a giant piano. Differently, Boyner has embraced this trend with their new "Dynamic Teen store" at Boyner İstinyePark in Istanbul, which focuses on sports and entertainment for Gen Z and Gen Alpha. Department stores can create lifelong customers by introducing children to shopping alongside their mothers, appealing to them as teenagers, and retaining them as young adults.

Mail-order sales were another revolutionary aspect introduced by department stores. Boucicaut's colourful catalogues helped Au Bon Marché reach people outside of Paris, making its products available to more customers. American retailers like Sears and Montgomery Ward in Chicago later perfected this model. Unlike the earlier French mail-order businesses, which targeted niche markets or elite customers, Ward's model was designed for the general public, particularly those in rural areas. He issued the first general merchandise catalogue in 1872, which was simple and easy to use, listing 163 items on a single sheet of paper. Ward also introduced innovative product return practices with the "satisfaction guaranteed or your money back" policy in 1875, which built customer trust and loyalty. This innovation was significant in the United States, where distance had previously made it hard for people to access various products. Department stores were indeed at the forefront of distance ordering and delivering customers to their homes.

Today, this foundation has transformed into e-commerce. Even though some department stores were late in the digital commerce race, the COVID-19 pandemic forced them to transform rapidly. They now offer options such as ordering in-store for home delivery and same-day delivery services that cater to the demand for instant gratification. Omnichannel strategies like "Buy Online, Pick Up In-Store" (BOPIS) blend the convenience of online shopping with the immediacy of in-store pickup. At the same time, integrated approaches ensure seamless transitions between online and offline experiences. By constantly observing their customers and sticking to their needs, these innovations provide convenience and satisfaction, prompting us to wonder what new innovations will define the next era of retail.

By putting women at the centre, department stores started a social revolution

Department stores played a significant role in the liberation and emancipation of women, transforming public spaces and social norms during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. These establishments offered women a socially acceptable venue to step outside their homes, facilitating a new form of public participation that was previously limited or entirely restricted.

Historically, women's presence in public spaces was heavily regulated and often frowned upon unless a man accompanied them. Middle-class women, in particular, faced societal scrutiny if seen unaccompanied in public, as this was associated with scandalous behaviour. The emergence of department stores began to change this dynamic. These retail palaces were designed to be inviting and luxurious, featuring elaborate displays, comfortable lounges, and various departments catering specifically to women's needs and desires. The store wasn’t just about shopping; it was about creating a space where women could socialise, explore, enjoy cultural events and assert their presence in the public realm without needing male accompaniment. Department stores' architectural design and marketing strategies were crucial in promoting this new public role for women. Stores like Le Bon Marché in Paris and Macy’s in New York were true social hubs.

Department stores also played a pivotal role in employing women, marking a significant step towards economic independence for women. Positions such as saleswomen allowed women to work outside their homes in a respectable environment, breaking away from traditional roles confined to domestic, agriculture and/or factory work. Despite extremely difficult working conditions and a highly patriarchal culture, this employment provided financial independence and fostered a sense of self-agency and personal growth. Like men, women could also occupy management positions. Overall, cities became more attractive as they transformed into job centres, another aspect of the social revolution department stores were part of.

In essence, department stores acted as catalysts for social change. They gave women unprecedented freedom to explore public spaces independently, engage in economic activities, and participate in the booming consumer culture. This newfound public presence was a first step towards gender equality, challenging and gradually altering the misogynistic norms that confined women to private, domestic spheres. So, the rise of department stores was a commercial revolution and a social one.

From shopping palaces to modern consumption and cultural landmarks

The department store in the late 19th century stood as a monument to the new bourgeoisie class and used its members' entrepreneurial drive to accelerate growth and create a profitable business model. The middle class of that time fed off of the material world; the wide variety of garments and surplus of goods catered to the bourgeoisie, who would flock to put themselves on display at these stores.

Department stores became the symbol of modernity, not only through their innovative architecture but also by pioneering a new commercial system that laid the groundwork for contemporary marketing. Large, vibrant advertising posters were on display at the exhibit, showcasing elegant dresses that embodied the desired lifestyle of the time — depicting scenes like women strolling on beaches and in city streets while dressed in their finest attire. Making department stores visible outside of their premises was crucial: for the first time in history, these ads showed the act of shopping driven by desire rather than necessity, creating what was later called consumption.

Also, department stores developed techniques based on the notion that customers are not merely buyers but visitors who have come to experience the grandeur of the store. Usually featuring unique and innovative architecture and located at the heart of cities, these stores transformed shopping into a leisurely activity akin to attending the theatre, portraying department stores as attractions first and shopping destinations second. Nowadays, retailers are increasingly curating experiences to attract and retain consumers. Despite changes in the retail landscape, they continue to employ strategies that emphasise their role as destinations, leveraging stunning architecture and interactive displays to create engaging environments.

Historically, department stores have been architectural marvels designed to impress and entice visitors, contributing to reshaping city centres. This tradition continues as modern department stores often feature innovative and beautiful designs that draw people in, creating a sense of wonder and luxury. For example, this is the case at the Hyundai Seoul, which has a large atrium filled with trees, and Birmingham's stunning Selfridges store building. In addition, window displays and in-store pop-ups remain central to the department store experience. These visually captivating presentations are designed to inspire desire and imagination, transforming shopping into an event. Interactive elements, such as live demonstrations, themed displays, and experiential zones, enhance this immersive experience, as is the case at SKP-S. Over time, they expanded their influence and revenue potential thanks to new ventures outside their original premises. Most expanded to secondary cities, with stores becoming the new city centre landmarks.

Department stores emerged as cultural landmarks, blending innovative architecture and immersive shopping experiences to attract and retain consumers. Today, they continue to adapt to modern retail challenges by integrating digital advancements and maintaining their status as cultural and social hubs. The focus on creating a memorable experience as a primary marketing strategy ensures that department stores remain relevant and enticing to a new age of consumers. They encourage repeat visits and customer loyalty by offering a unique environment that combines shopping with entertainment and leisure. In the modern landscape, where department stores compete alongside e-tailers, positioning themselves as cultural and social hubs is more than ever pertinent to maintaining their appeal. The development of the department store from the early days of Le Bon Marché in Paris to today’s global retail giants shows their resilience and ability to adapt, innovate, and thrive in the dynamic industry. Reflecting on the rich history and impact of department stores on society, it is apparent that their evolution over time has shaped not only the retail sector but also cultural norms, paving the way for future innovations in commerce and retail. Their story is one of continuous change, a testament to their foundational role in the commercial and social fabric of society.

Credits: IADS (Katie Clark & Morghan Pollard)

Printable version here

Check out the pictures here

After years of speculation, Dover Street Market, the renowned fashion concept store founded by Rei Kawakubo of Comme des Garçons and husband Adrian Joffe, finally opened a new location in Paris. Located in the Marais area, the new store is the 7th location to open over the last 20 years after Tokyo, London, Beijing, New York, Los Angeles and Singapore (not to mention Dover Street Market Parfums opened in Paris in October 2019). Kawakubo and Joffe After took over the building in 2019, but soon after, they decided to wait until the pandemic was over and tourism normalised to open the store. From 2021 to 2023, the gorgeous 17th-century Hôtel de Coulanges (once the house of French writer Madame de Sevigné) temporarily housed a non-profit cultural hub (“le 35-37”, after the street number the building is located at) hosting art exhibitions, fashion shows, temporary fashion markets and art performances. All these events supported the anticipation and excitement around the space opening and secured a break on taxes and rent. After this long delay, the much-anticipated store finally opened to consumers on Friday, 24 May 2024. What can one expect from this latest Dover Street Market family addition? Paris is seen as the fashion capital, but will the store succeed in the long run?

Dover Street Market's Paris location: a unique ecosystem approach

The store spans 1,100 sqm on 3 floors and is centred around a courtyard accessible from the street (rue des Francs-Bourgeois). The store occupies the ground and first floors of the building and parts of the basement. Kawakubo designed the store and said she wanted its design to be a statement in itself, focusing not on selling garments (clothes are not visible from the street, for example) “but rather a space in which shoppers can immerse themselves.” Considering the historical nature of the building, the store is a succession of rooms (some are relatively small). The retail space is genuinely immersive, if not too much of a labyrinth, making it easy to miss parts of the store. The customer journey starts on the ground floor. Then, the staff recommends continuing in the basement on the first floor before ending up in another part of the ground floor.

When exiting the store, customers can seamlessly access other experiential parts immediately accessible through the next-door entrance. More of an ecosystem than a store, Dover Street Market also includes a Rose Bakery coffee shop (as is the case in the other retailer’s locations) with a terrace and 2 different basements (-1 and -2 floors) offering 2 exhibition spaces, making the store a genuinely experiential destination. At the time of the opening, one of the exhibitions was about the Bovan label, and the other showed pictures of the long-time collaboration between Comme des Garçons and photograph Paolo Roversi. That’s not all there is. Not accessible to the customers, the upper floors house the Dover Street Market’s brand development team, offices and various spaces to host events and showrooms for the roaster of brands supported by the company (and sold in the store).

What about the store concept? In many parts of the store, the interior design takes cues from the big white curved furniture and counters that one can find in the Tokyo Aoyama Comme des Garçons store. In other parts (especially in the basement), racks and displays are made of industrial steel poles and tubes, highlighted by coloured neon lights. Very few colours are used besides white, with a baby blue or a light pink wall here and there. Floors alternate raw concrete and old hardwood pavement. The natural light floods almost all parts of the store. Overall, this store does not include the kind of impressive props usually punctuating the other Dover Street Markets locations (such as the gigantic pillar covered in knitwear in the NYC store or the gigantic bugs in the Tokyo store). However, the retailer’s identity is visible. The staff is plenty and reflects the store style.

The challenges and opportunities of independent fashion

Unlike their other locations, Dover Street Market Paris almost exclusively focuses on independent fashion labels under the wholesale business model and does not include global luxury brand concessions. Even though the store business model might consist of consignment deals, this business model makes a big difference in terms of investments and operations. According to CEO Adrian Joffe, small independent designer brands' biggest challenge is the lack of a platform to showcase their work (especially after Matches Fashion collapse). As such, Dover Street Market is an excellent window for these labels.

Brands and products are mixed, with no visible gender, category, or price logic for a customer journey starting on the ground floor, continuing in the basement, on the first floor, before ending up in another part of the ground floor. The result of this unusual mix creates a diverse and refreshing shopping experience. The store houses many brands (the lists below are not exhaustive):

• Ground floor: Comme des Garçons is the first brand upon store entrance. Many of its sub-labels are available (Play, Black, Shirt, Homme Plus, Homme Deux, Girl…) and are to be found on each floor. Other brands are Melitta Baumeister, Junya Watanabe, Noir Kei Ninomiya, Vaquera.
• Basement: Erl, Jacquemus, Online Ceramics , Bovan, Rassvet, Loutre, MM6, Zomer, Kidill, Kartik Research, Human Made, Westfall.
• First floor: Meta Campagna Collective, Bottega Venetta men mixed with Random Identities and Prada men, Walter van Beirendonck, Objet Trouvé, Doublet, Willy Chavarria, Charles Jeffrey Loverboy, JW Anderson, Rick Owens, Lido, Simone Rocha, The Shepherd, Undercover, Bottega Venetta women, Miu Miu and Prada women, Marine Serre, Ponte, Cecilie Bahnsen, Duran Lantink, Sacai, Molly Goddard, Junya Watanabe Man, Jah Jah, Kiko Kostadinov, Eckhaus Latta. The first floor also has a room dedicated to sneakers, which will probably be a key source of revenue.
• Second part of the ground floor: Nicolo Pasqualetti, Wales Bonner, Marc Jacobs, Craig Green, Hed Mayner.

There are almost no brands from the LVMH group (aside from JW Anderson and Marc Jacobs selections) and the Kering group. Among the big global brands, only a short assortment of Prada, Miu Miu, and Bottega Venetta offer luxury products.

This radical approach is indeed a risky bet on independent fashion. Even though prices are not low, the store cannot rely on high-priced Louis Vuitton, Loewe or jewellery products as in other Dover Street Market locations.

Will it work?

Considering the traffic, choosing a location in the Marais seems a safe bet, but it doesn’t come without risks for a retailer like Dover Street Market. The Marais’ reputation is to be a stylish and trendy area. Still, it is now more of another outlet for blockbuster fashion and beauty brands such as Sandro, Maje, Diptyque or Kiehl’s, to name a few, than an area for edgy and independent fashion to thrive. Also, despite tourists flooding the streets and relatively wealthy people living there, luxury brands failed to establish themselves in the neighbourhood, showing the Marais is not the right area for them. Dover Street Market customers are usually luxury fans, so will they be convinced by the assortment?

As said, independent fashion is another risky bet. Once they see how it works, Dover Street Market is said to discontinue around 20 brands from the next buying season to focus on the most successful ones, as it seems obvious that not all of the countless labels will find their audience. On the other hand, Paris misses a concept store like Colette. There is undoubtedly a vacant spot here for Dover Street Market to cater to the Paris fashion crowd. Also, these labels are offering more accessible price points (t-shirts start at €100), so it will be an opportunity for customers to buy a chunk of hype at a low cost.

Professional press and Paris fashion people have gushed about the success of the opening. According to BoF, traffic on the first day was 2,500 people with a 20% conversion rate, generating €75,000 (including Rose Bakery turnover) for a €40,000 budget. The average basket was €150, which seems relatively small for a store like Dover Street Market. Figures on the second trading day (the first Saturday of opening) were not disclosed. The store targets €12 million in revenue in the first full year of trading and aims to reach profitability in the second year at around €15 million. BoF mentioned that previous locations needed 3 to 5 years to break even.

The opening of Dover Street Market in Paris marks a significant addition to the retailer’s global footprint, introducing an immersive retail experience in the historic Marais district. This new location, designed by Rei Kawakubo, emphasizes an ecosystem approach rather than a traditional store layout, incorporating art exhibitions, a Rose Bakery coffee shop, and spaces dedicated to brand development and events. By focusing primarily on independent fashion labels and avoiding reliance on major luxury brands, Dover Street Market Paris offers a distinctive and diverse shopping experience different from other high-end boutiques and department stores in the city. Despite the fashion market challenges and the inherent risks of promoting small designer brands, the initial response has been promising. The store has seen significant foot traffic and sales, reflecting its potential to fill the void left by previous concept stores like Colette. Dover Street Market could become a hub for fashion enthusiasts seeking niche brands and an alternative shopping experience underlined by a true sense of community.

Credits: IADS (Christine Montard)

Printable version here

The IADS was thrilled to attend the 2024 Viva Technology conference last May in Paris, eagerly seeking out key trends and exciting startups that could bring value to our members. VivaTech 2024 broke new ground with record-breaking attendance of 165,000 visitors, a 10% increase over last year. The event buzzed with energy, attracting 13,500 startups from over 25 business sectors and over 2,000 investors. One hundred twenty countries were represented, solidifying VivaTech’s central position on the global tech panorama.

At VivaTech 2024, the interaction between startups and tech champions highlighted a significant trend in the tech industry. The event not only emphasised established tech companies' dominance but also showcased the boundless innovative potential of startups.

Key themes included artificial intelligence, retail, climate technology, and mobility solutions. Despite the prominence of major corporations, the event still celebrated start-ups. VivaTech 2024 facilitated connections between startups, investors, and corporate partners, promoting an ecosystem where emerging companies could flourish alongside tech champions. This balance indicates that while tech champions are undeniably powerful, the startup dream is far from over. Startups continue to be essential drivers of innovations, especially in niche markets and emerging technology sectors. Our non-exhaustive review below highlights the most relevant retail trends we spotted this year for our members.

Tech champions vs. startups: is this the dawn of realpolitik in tech?

While having traditionally communicated on the startup ecosystem to promote a certain mindset in technology, this year, VivaTech concentrated on "tech champions", referring to companies that play a crucial role in shaping the technology sectors in their respective countries.

These companies have the economic power and capacity to promote innovation, attract talent, create jobs, and boost investment and exports. They can dominate their domestic markets and grab a significant share of global markets. Their size can even sometimes surpass country economies: if Nvidia, a chipmaker, was a country, it would be the 12th largest economy in the world after Mexico.

Tech champions are crucial for the growth of digital economies, as they create other similar enterprises, put significant resources into innovation ecosystems, and integrate new products at a global scale. They also provide practical exit opportunities to startup entrepreneurs and invest heavily in research and development. Overall, some believe that developing tech champions is crucial for the growth and competitiveness of digital economies, and countries must adopt the right policies and strategies to support their emergence.

It is notable, however, that not all players share this vision. Many, such as Meta's tech scientist Yann LeCun, are also calling for more control over these companies.

Many startups can potentially become tech champions, especially if they demonstrate innovative solutions, vigorous growth, and strategic approaches to scaling. Tech champions are companies that play a pivotal role in the global technology industry, driving innovation, attracting talent, creating jobs, and boosting investment and exports. Startups can achieve this status by following strategic approaches and developing necessary economies of scale and scope.

AI in retail goes beyond chatbots and copywriting.

AI continued to reign and dominate the event this year as companies showcased new and more concrete AI-powered use cases from fashion, beauty products, and payment systems. Below is a subjective curated selection of some of the most inspiring and exciting start-ups we spotted at VivaTech:

• Lowe’s Lowebot (retail): Lowebot is a prototype exploring how Autonomous Retail Service Robot (ARSR) technology can improve and enhance in-store service within a large-scale retail environment. It is designed to help customers with more straightforward needs navigate throughout the store and guide them to the product they are looking for, allowing them to get in and out quickly with exactly what they need. On a sales associate level, Lowebot is designed to enhance the employees’ ability to serve customers by addressing simple questions, focusing on more complex queries and delivering trusted project advice. Additionally, Lowebots allows for the streamlined processes and facilitation of real-time inventory and patterns across the enterprise.
• imki (fashion): Augmented and creative AI for luxury and fashion; a creative process with tailor-made, specialised, secure, and responsible solutions. They offer their clients specialised “business” AI bots, the bots having explicitly been trained, and they guarantee accuracy, precision, and efficiency. AI bots are adapted to the clients, driven by their brand DNA. They integrate their codes, the foundation of the brand, and their identifying product attributes. When brands integrate imki into their process, they reduce the time from the first creative explorations to the design phase and then to the product realisation. As a result, the product is brought to the market faster, reducing the risk of unsold, overstocked, and wasteful products.
• xydrobe (fashion): xydrobe collaborates with luxury brands to create narratives for customers. Their platform offers brands a unique opportunity to weave their stories into immersive virtual worlds, engaging the audience on a deeper level. Physical meets virtual, whether through the one-person xydrobe Pod or multi-person VR cinema, delivering one-of-a-kind experiences.
• Scentronics (fragrances): Scentronics was created on the belief that the era of mass perfumery is over. People no longer want to smell the same under the “rule” of brands. By breaking the traditional supplier-brand-retailer model to create and distribute scents, they bring actual value to consumers. Scentronics is the first AI-driven public scent creation platform. The customers' personal data (such as likes, dislikes, what makes them happy or sad) is collected via an intuitive web app, applied to the matching scent, and one’s perfume is made. These machines are currently found in over 45 countries, and the number is growing. They have three different scale models, each holding several ingredients, and can make a certain number of samples or bottles per hour, depending on the scale model.
• Lunu (payment systems): parallel to the product category innovations, we also spotted this startup that offers payment terminals to support a wide range of cryptocurrencies and wallets, making such transactions as easy as using a credit card.

Case study: AI and robotics are transforming inventory management

As every retailer knows, keeping inventory track has become more complicated given the amount of stock to move online and offline.

AI algorithms allow more accurate and data-driven decision-making processes. They optimise stock levels by analysing vast amounts of data, ensuring the right products are available at the right time. This reduces the risk of stockouts and overstocking, improving customer satisfaction and profitability.

AI-powered systems use historical sales data, market trends, and external factors to predict demand accurately. This enables retailers to make informed decisions about inventory replenishment, avoiding overstocking and costly markdowns, referred to as predictive demand forecasting. It also automates tasks such as updating inventory levels, reordering products, and predicting demands. Automating inventory management minimises human error and ensures optimal inventory levels, reducing the need for manual intervention.

AI and robotics automate inventory tracking, reducing the time and effort required for manual counting and coding. This improves accuracy and efficiency in inventory management.

These AI algorithms analyse customer preferences and purchase patterns to offer personalised inventory management, ensuring the right products are stocked at the right place and time. AI and robotics are integrated with supply chain operations to optimise inventory distribution across various locations, reducing transportation costs and improving overall operational efficiency.

AI-powered systems monitor inventory levels and sales data to prevent discrepancies and identify issues, ensuring products are consistently available for customers. Some of the top start-ups we found that are revolutionising supply chains with AI and robotics are:

• Trax: Provides in-store solutions using computer vision, machine learning, and hardware like cameras and autonomous robots to gather real-time data about shelf availability.
• Standard Cognition: Develops AI-powered checkout systems that allow customers to grab what they want without needing to go to a cashier.
• Trigo: Develops AI-based automated retail checkout systems, which can be seen in many different types of retail and service establishments with varying degrees of complexity. The common thread is the empowerment of customers, enabling them to complete transactions at their own pace.
• Sentient: Develops AI solutions for website experimentation and e-commerce recommendations that can transform customer experiences and increase conversions.
• Bossa Nova: This company produces robots for retail stores that scan shelves to help employees restock and track where items are located.
• Everseen: Uses computer vision to prevent theft at self-checkout counters.
• AiFi: develops store automation systems using AI and robotics. Its camera-first frictionless checkout experience allows shoppers to anonymously purchase items in-store without having to wait in line, stop to scan, or pay.

AI was not the only topic to take the stage, as sustainability remains an area for innovation

Sustainability remains a hot topic, and the event highlighted green technologies and sustainable solutions to reduce the environmental impact of digital technology. This included innovations in transportation, logistics, and energy efficiency.

CNN International gave a masterclass on how CNN is adapting its approach to sustainable storytelling.

Producing commercials can be unsustainable due to all the work and travel that goes into creating them. CNN started Create, an award-winning brand studio that works with a broad range of global brands to bring their stores to life, to the team space, TV, digital, and social.

Retail businesses can follow CNN Create’s lead by integrating sustainability into their operations, from transportation and material use to waste management and energy consumption. By doing so, they can significantly reduce their environmental impact and appeal to the growing market of eco-conscious consumers.

Create examines six critical areas: transport, material, disposal, fuel, and space. To reduce air travel emissions, Create sends smaller crews and uses local/remote crews. Where possible, Create will aim to use electric and hybrid vehicles.

As for material, Create will encourage all relevant parties of their productions to cut meat from catering and restrict the use of plastics. Regarding disposal, Create will follow the AdGreen ‘waste hierarchy’ of “Reduce, Reuse, Recycle, Recover, and Dispose” to aim for higher reuse and recycling rates. As for fuel, Create will use electric vehicles where possible and opt for petrol instead of diesel. Lastly, Create will explore energy-saving solutions and find ways to ensure that space can be powered by renewable energy.

Create continues its mission to obtain carbon-neutral certification for global film productions and events and has joined Ad Net Zero to help reach this goal. They place sustainability stories at the centre of campaigns and ensure all films and events are produced with our carbon footprint in front of our minds.

VivaTechnology 2024 demonstrated the enduring significance of startups in driving innovation, even as tech champions continue to dominate the industry landscape. The event highlighted the complementary roles of both entities: tech champions with their extensive resources and global reach, and startups with their agility and innovative prowess. Key themes such as AI in retail, sustainability, and the evolving realpolitik of tech underscored the potential for synergistic growth. By fostering connections between startups, investors, and corporate partners, VivaTech 2024 reinforced the idea that the startup dream remains vibrant and essential. As startups and established companies navigate this dynamic ecosystem, their collaboration and competition will continue to propel technological advancements and economic growth.

Credits: IADS (Elisabetta Falco Beccalli)

Printable version here

Check out the pictures here

Brand differentiation through a strong and relevant positioning is commonplace. The leading brands are built-in with clear added value and customer promise, meaning that the best-in-class are often pre-empting a whole category in the minds of customers. For example, Louis Vuitton is linked to “the art of travel” (a phrase which encapsulates its origins as a trunk manufacturer, its positioning as a luxury brand, and connotes an idea of freedom of movement), Nike relates to sports and performance, and Emirates Airline with the notion of travelling in style. This is true as well for branded retailers: Apple’s appeal is all about uncompromising quality high-tech lifestyle, Zara about high fashion at affordable prices, and The Gap about quality apparel at the right price.

For brands and branded retailers, such differentiation in the minds of customers is achieved through heavy marketing investments, allowing them to establish a clear positioning which is at the core of their business.

Third-party retailers, such as department stores, are in a different position, especially for the larger ones. For a long time, they were seen by both businesses and customers as “houses of brands” and, as such, able to talk to anyone, proposing “everything under the same roof” (JCPenney was promising in 2006 “It’s all inside. For all the sides of you”, and well before that, Harrods’ motto was “all things for all people, everywhere” in Latin). For that reason, they were positioning themselves as being a crossroads (in Paris, well-known slogans like “everything can be found at La Samaritaine” and “there is always something going on at Le Bon Marché”), places of constant discovery (Manor’s slogan is “Special Everyday”, Isetan Shinjuku’s promise in the 1960s was “everyday is new. Isetan is for fashion”), or pre-empted the authoritative position of being the leading fashion destination (Harvey Nichols slogan in the 1950s was “London’s leading fashion house”, Peek & Cloppenburg was “House of Fashion” in 2000, and Dillard’s “the style of your life” in 2009). The notion of price was also important: in 2001 Arnotts was promising to be “the heart of style and value” while John Lewis has long committed to “never knowingly undersell”.

However, a brand promise based on being the place to be, at the edge of fashion, or at the best price, is quite difficult to sustain in the digital age when the Internet precisely allows the creation of massive digital marketplaces, giving access to the most obscure fashion in a millisecond, and always with the possibility to compare prices with retailers across the planet.

Some department stores have resisted thanks to their historical advantage: Harrods or KaDeWe’s reputation about luxury is universal (KaDeWe’s slogan in 2004 was “the fine art of first-class shopping”) while Galeries Lafayette is recognized as a place where fashion is much more than a mere promise, by giving access to every trend from across the planet.

But what happens when the goal is to pre-empt a new market, far from the historical moneymakers that luxury, fashion, cosmetics, or home categories have represented for department stores?

Last September, for the first time, IADS member Boyner, in Turkey, hostedtheir “Boyner Dynamic” event: 3 days of outdoor activities and gatherings to establish Boyner as the leading lifestyle destination in the country. The catch? Nothing was to be sold. It was all about gathering people together and animating a community. Let’s review it.

Boyner’s strategic goals are to capitalize on a perfect trifecta of changes, with the country, customers and market changing

We reviewed Boyner’s history in an IADS Exclusive earlier in 2022. What came up clearly about the situation the company found itself in was that a change was needed due to macroeconomic shifts in the country:

• The country’s population is younger than in Europe, but ageing: the median age is 33.5 years old (to be compared with 28.3 years old in 2007), with half of the population aged less than 30 years old.
• This population is urban (77% live in cities), connected to the Internet (95.5% of the 15-24 years old and 80.8% of the 25-74 years old) and healthy: life expectancy in Turkey is 77.31 years (the same as in Europe), 9 years more than in 2000, and a whopping 20 years more than in 1980 (while, in Europe, life expectancy was above 70 years in 1980).

As such, the average Turkish customers know trends and are well informed about brands. In parallel, the notions of nature, environment and health have become much more important than in the past.

In parallel, Boyner underwent some significant changes, as we reported in our previous paper: it transformed from being a manufacturer-turned-retailer in the 1950s to a branded distribution group, active in many verticals, and heavily relying on its private labels, appealing to the middle class.

This strategy worked until a few years ago, and 2020 represented an inflexion in the strategy with the release of a new store concept acting as the visible part of a new company approach to the market. Sensing that customers were evolving and starting to ask for something else, especially the younger ones, Boyner decided to pivot in the following areas:

• They decided to become a “lifestyle multi-brand destination”, combining private labels and international brands, selected, curated and presented in a way which appealed to and made sense for the new generation of customers,
• Anchoring the stores in their neighbouring communities was also key, as price was not seen as a sufficient differentiation point anymore. Sustainability and wellness were identified as key differentiation points, in tune with customers’ new preoccupations.
• Proposing a set of new innovative digital services, including state-of-the-art apps and a 90-minutes delivery service, Boyner Now, to easily blend into customers’ lives while at the same time facilitating the data harvest.

As a consequence, new stores were opened which reflected exactly this: vibrant locations with a different approach according to the neighbourhood (the first iteration, Cadde, located in the Asian part of Istanbul, has a different look & feel from the latest unit to have opened, in the posh Istinye Park location), but all promoting the notion of a sustainable lifestyle, good for the planet and oneself (this was also a very astute way to differentiate from the other large retail company in the country, Beymen, a former entity of Boyner, which is fully focused on trendy fashion and luxury).

However, Boyner’s top management also realized that new stores, and money invested in marketing campaigns, were a necessary, but not sufficient, condition for success: they had to find ways to change the Turkish customers’ perception of them (especially the younger ones), not an easy feat knowing that the company, and the brand name, have been around for 70 years. This is how they came up with the idea of the Boyner Dynamic Fest.

What was the Boyner Dynamic Fest?

Last September, Boyner organized a festival over a sunny weekend, in Istanbul’s largest open-air park, to “celebrate its passion for active life”. More specifically, this meant that Boyner organized a multi-faceted event designed to entertain its customers and celebrate a sporty lifestyle:

• The first day opened with a morning run, and participants were then invited to take part in dance workshops, workout routines, yoga sessions and other communal activities over the weekend which were striking in terms of the level of participation from many different generations of people,
• It was also possible to practice sports, thanks to a basketball court, a soccer field, gym machines and bikes in the open air,
• Nutritionists and life coaches were also animating workshops to explain more about the work-life balance, and Boyner completed this approach by inviting Turkish Olympic athletes on stage to share their experience with the crowd,
• A kid’s zone was organized where children could play, spend energy, practice face painting, or design wooden shoes.
• The 2 days were also peppered with concerts and public performances from Turkish singers and celebrities.

The event also aimed at communicating on the topics of sustainability. For this reason, participants were invited to step for charities: 1.3m steps were given to 11 non-governmental organizations in the domains of health, sport, and education. Also, the whole event was designed to be waste-free: rubbish was collected and recycled (7,000 plastic bottles and 4.5 tons of garbage were recycled), including the decor (500m2 of vinyl was upcycled) and raw material (6 tons of water used during the event were used in agricultural irrigation after the event, and 3,600 nails used in the festival were removed and reused).

All in all, the event looked like a very pleasant festival, which ticked all the boxes in terms of encouraging a healthy, green, and responsible lifestyle, but mixing it with enjoyable experiences and learning. As the Boyner CEO put it after the event, “We feel responsible for social goods on issues that affect everyone, such as the good life, and we always take steps that we combine with experience”.

What was so special about the Boyner Dynamic Fest?

From a participant’s point of view, this event looked like a very cool and enjoyable weekend full of activities that could be practiced in open-air, with family and friends. The fact that entrance was free of charge probably also helped.

However, a closer look at how the event was built showed some interesting features.

First, while the event entrance was free, participants had to register through a dedicated platform, independent from the existing Boyner ecosystem (the Boyner Dynamic Fest was advertised on a regional basis independently from the retail platforms). All in all, the event attracted a crowd of 6,000 people, which means that this event was a good deal in terms of customer data acquisition and the ability to contact them, even if they are not customers yet, in the future.

Also, another interesting point is that many brands took part in the event. In a dedicated area, a village of brands was built, with names such as Adidas, ASICS, DC, Jack&Jones, Levi’s, MACFit, Merrell, Puma, Skechers and Under Armour. Boyner astutely convinced this specific set of brands, which is perfectly aligned with the healthy and sporty purpose of this event, to take part in the festival. It should be noted that not only were brands not paid nor given perks to take part in this event, but they also had to pay for the set-up of their tents and product displays. The fact that this festival was a completely unprecedented initiative probably helped convince them, but Boyner’s argument was more striking: it was, for those brands, a great way to be associated with a retailer striving hard to be recognized as the champion of lifestyle, sport, and health in Turkey.

And this went through one of the most striking aspects of this whole festival: nothing was for sale.

It was all about customer education and experience and giving them the possibility to discover brands and products in a relaxed, no-strings-attached environment. The fact that no transaction was involved probably helped people ask questions about products and services without the fear of being lured into purchasing something at the end.

Boyner also made a good deal in terms of content, since all brands were more than happy to bring with them their own stories and customer-oriented content, adding to the richness of the event.

The fact that the whole event was free, without even making a product out of participants, made it quite interesting in terms of approach. Boyner dedicated a significant amount of time, energy, people and money to organizing an event that was not designed to directly contribute to its P&L. It was instead seen as a marketing investment, but designed in such a way that its free and generous aspect would encourage the crowd to participate even more and, ultimately, associate Boyner with the values that were championed during this event.

Some consumer brands already have such an approach of making marketing investments without any hope of ROI, just to pre-empt a specific positioning or customer perception. This is exactly what the President of Coca-Cola explained during the IADS CEO call in January: the company was directly investing in consumer marketing even though they do not have any B to C activity in Europe, as they rely only on the activity of their distributor (their bottler). They see these investments as “holistic”:

• They allow placing the brand close to the customer,
• They make their partners successful.

If, in this case, such “disinterested” investments are understandable, they are less common on retailers’ side: after all, department stores have always insisted brands should invest in trade marketing to promote their names to the final customer, even though this also contributed to the department store to being perceived as the exclusive place to find them.

Boyner’s initiative of financing their brand equity without any ROI expectation is uncommon at this stage but is also part of a larger trend where department stores have to invest in their brand perception to make sure they stay relevant to their audience or attract a new one. For instance, when Magasin du Nord invested to open a popup in Malmö, Sweden (where they do not have any activities), the purpose was not so much to generate sales but to create brand equity. Brand equity’s efficiency was proven when Breuninger renamed the recently acquired Konen store in Munich with its name, sales soared even though the upgrade works had not started yet.

Department stores cannot rely only on their featured brands’ marketing efforts to differentiate themselves through selection and curation, they need to stand for the values they aim to promote. In this perspective, the Boyner Dynamic Fest is a great example of a genuinely disinterested operation, included in a broader marketing scheme, which contributes to building brand equity, one brick at a time.

Credits: IADS (Selvane Mohandas du Ménil)

What: Japan's luxury market is experiencing a significant sales spike driven by international tourists capitalizing on a weak yen, resilient domestic spending, and retail upgrades.

Why it is important: This boom underscores the dynamic nature of the luxury market in Japan, highlighting the influence of favorable exchange rates, the importance of local consumer resilience, and the strategic responses of luxury brands to evolving market conditions.

Japan's luxury market has seen a substantial increase in sales, fueled by a combination of international tourists taking advantage of a weak yen and strong domestic spending, particularly among wealthier Gen X consumers. International tourists, especially from China, South Korea, the US, and Australia, have contributed to record-high duty-free sales in Japanese department stores. Luxury brands like Hermès, Tiffany & Co., and Balenciaga are expanding their presence in Japan, driven by the surge in demand. The favorable exchange rates have made Japan an attractive shopping destination, encouraging significant spending on luxury goods. Additionally, Japanese locals continue to support the luxury market despite economic challenges, showcasing the market's resilience. The future growth of Japan's luxury market will depend on brands' ability to remain relevant to local consumers, capture younger generations, and adapt to changing consumer trends and economic conditions.

What’s behind Japan’s luxury boom?

What: Customers are in an expectative position in the US

Why it is important: The global context is hitting all markets and affecting consumption everywhere

In June, the US Conference Board Consumer Confidence Index experienced a slight decline, dropping to 100.4 from a revised May reading of 101.3, mainly due to a decrease in the expectations component from 74.9 to 73.0. This decrease slightly reversed a nearly 6-point increase observed in May. Although confidence regarding current conditions remains robust, largely supported by a strong labor market, there is caution that any increase in unemployment or other signs of labor market weakening could diminish consumer confidence in the future.

Despite the dip, consumer confidence levels have stayed within a relatively consistent range observed over the past few years, suggesting that the decrease does not signify a notably negative trend. Consumers are displaying a cautious demeanor but are not overly alarmed, continuing to express concerns primarily about high prices, especially for food and groceries.

Other economic indicators such as recent stock market highs and falling gasoline prices, which normally would lift consumer confidence, seem to have had limited impact due to the prevailing cautious sentiment. Inflation expectations have slightly decreased from 5.4% to 5.3%, and there is a reduced anticipation of rising interest rates in the near future. Overall, consumer sentiment in June reflects a sustained unease, neither worsening significantly nor showing marked improvement.

In the US, consumer confidence in a sustained unease

What: An opinion piece on the relevance of travel retail

Why it is important: we are at the dawn of pre-pandemic record-breaking levels in international tourism, however, the nature of the business may have changed.

The travel retail industry has faced significant challenges, particularly with a 70% decline in activity due to Covid-19. Recovery is slow, with expectations to return to pre-pandemic levels only by next year. Despite the convenience of domestic and international e-commerce, travel retail offers unique, experience-driven opportunities that brands are leveraging to enhance consumer engagement.

Travel retail encounters a unique contradiction: airports provide ample dwell time, promoting aimless browsing, yet the window for actual shopping is limited by factors like check-in and immigration processes, which can disengage potential buyers. This tension creates a hyper-competitive environment during the critical 'golden hour' where attention to retail fundamentals and staff effectiveness becomes crucial. Staff play a pivotal role in converting interest into sales, particularly with diverse international customers.

To capitalize on its unique position, travel retail must innovate and adapt to the tech-savacity of modern consumers. Emphasizing pre-trip engagement through digital strategies like personalized emails, social media ads, and mobile notifications can enhance the chances of conversion. Ultimately, success in travel retail hinges on understanding and integrating into the shopper’s journey, creating memorable experiences and investing in skilled staff to navigate the complexities of this unique market.

Is travel retail still relevant?

What: Customers are increasingly looking at cross border options for cheaper prices, especially in Asia.

Why it is important: who should bear the cost of returns then, the retailer of the customer? Retailers face a complex balance between managing return fees and maintaining customer satisfaction in cross-border transactions. A significant portion of consumers, especially in India where 60% expect free returns, demand cost-free return policies. This expectation extends broadly across the Asia Pacific region, driven by a desire for a hassle-free return process. Despite this consumer demand, the Asendia’s Shipping and Returns report highlights a trend away from free returns due to financial unsustainability, with less than half of online retailers currently offering this service. Brands like Zara and Asos.com are pivoting towards charging for returns or using subscription models to offset costs. The introduction of return fees can potentially deter customers, impacting sales and loyalty, particularly in regions like South Korea, Switzerland, the UAE, and India, where there is greater acceptance of these charges. Retailers are exploring strategies to balance these dynamics by offering free returns on promotional items or during specific periods, and investing in technology to minimize returns and enhance shopping experiences. Furthermore, according to DHL’s Global Online Shopper Survey 2023, price incentives are a major motivator for cross-border shopping, with significant percentages of consumers in Brazil, Malaysia, and Thailand citing lower costs as their primary reason for purchasing abroad. Quality is another critical factor, particularly in Sub-Saharan Africa and the MENA region. Retailers also need to consider additional trust-building measures, such as ensuring well-packaged goods, transparent consumer policies, multilingual websites, and sustainability practices like carbon offsetting. These elements are essential for fostering consumer confidence in cross-border shopping, particularly in diverse markets with varying expectations on return policies.

How can retailers balance cross-border return fees and customer satisfaction?

What: Luxury e-commerce companies like Mytheresa, Ssense, and Moda Operandi are staying afloat by focusing on specific consumer bases, curating their product assortments, and maintaining retail fundamentals, despite the challenging market conditions.

Why it is important: The success strategies of these luxury e-tailers highlight the importance of targeting a defined audience, prioritizing profitability over aggressive growth, and emphasizing customer experience.

In a challenging luxury e-commerce market, Mytheresa, Ssense, and Moda Operandi are surviving by honing in on specific consumer segments, curating their product offerings, and excelling in retail fundamentals. These companies avoid competing on price, instead focusing on exclusivity, superior service, and targeted marketing. Mytheresa continues to see sales growth by engaging high-end clients with exclusive events and products. Ssense caters to Gen-Z with emerging designers and creative content, while Moda Operandi attracts runway enthusiasts with virtual trunk shows. Despite their successes, these strategies could limit scalability and raise questions about the market's capacity to sustain multiple players. The luxury sector faces slower growth and higher customer-acquisition costs, challenging e-tailers to maintain their value propositions. As the market evolves, the focus on unit economics and operational efficiency will be crucial for long-term resilience.

Navigating travel retail’s post-pandemic revival

What: A new wave of independent boutiques is carving out a path for success by prioritizing brick-and-mortar offerings, curating unique assortments, and betting on emerging labels amid the struggles of department stores and online giants.

Why it is important: This shift in the retail landscape opens up opportunities for small, specialty stores to thrive by focusing on local communities, unique in-store experiences, and personalized service, challenging the dominance of larger, more impersonal retail models.

As department stores and e-commerce giants face challenges, a new generation of independent boutiques is emerging, creating a healthier, more sustainable model for luxury retail. These specialty stores, like ESSX, The Webster, Dover Street Market, and Café Forgot, prioritize in-person shopping experiences and unique, curated assortments. They often opt out of competing in the online retail space, focusing instead on providing a distinctive and intimate shopping experience that cannot be replicated online. By taking risks on emerging designers and catering to local tastes, these boutiques offer something different from the monotony of larger retailers. The trend highlights a shift towards more personalized, community-focused retail, where smaller stores can thrive by staying true to their strengths and serving their niche markets effectively.

The stores defining a new era of multi-brand retail

What: NRF report on Retail Circularity: an action guide for retailers

Why it is important: A guide developed for retail executives and teams as they explore and implement circular business models. Also a resource prepared as a tool to highlight circular retail opportunities, and more.

The Retail Circularity Action Guide 2024, by Deloitte and the National Retail Federation (NRF), focuses on the challenges and opportunities for retailers to adopt circular business models. The report highlights the need for retailers to transition from traditional linear product lifecycles to more sustainable and circular practices.

In order to create the report, NRF shared a 13 question circularity survey, receiving back 100 individual survey responses, and 83 unique company responses.

They found that there were 4 main key challenges in order to adopt circular business models.

Firstly, access to alternative materials. Retailers need greater access to recycled and alternative materials to design and produce circular products at scale.  Secondly the industry standards.  The safety of existing products, quality, and shipping standards are not designed with circularity in mind, requiring industry-level changes. Supply chain and Infrastructure was the third challenge.  Retailers struggle to collect and supply products for circular models due to limited access to high-quality recovered materials, post-customer products, and parts for repair.  And lastly recycling and tracking. Advancements in recycling solutions and infrastructure are needed to lower costs, and retailers need better tracking and grading systems to monitor product disposal and recycling.

The report outlines several strategies for retailers to adopt and implement circular business models.

These were:

1. Product Design: Designing products that can be repaired, reused, resold, or recycled at end of life.
2. Collection and Reverse Logistics: Implementing collection programs to take back used products and partner with third-party organizations for efficient reverse logistics.
3. Resale and Rental: Offering resale and rental programs to extend product lifecycles and create new revenue streams.
4. Repair and Refurbishment: Providing repair services to extend product lifecycles and enhance customer loyalty.
5. Recycling: Developing recycling programs to process and sell recycled materials, reducing waste and environmental impact.

The report emphasizes the importance of consistent company wide strategy, and support from leaders to  successfully implement circular business models. It also highlights the need for retailers to track and measure the effectiveness of these initiatives through various criteria, such as revenue growth, customer engagement, and environmental impact.

NRF Report: Retail Circularity

What: CBRE forecasts that foot traffic in retail locations will exceed pre-pandemic levelsin 2025.

Why it is important: This does not mean that stores just have to wait for traffic to come back: the need to adapt and radically transform themselves.

Retail foot traffic in major shopping areas is projected to exceed pre-pandemic levels by 2025, with CBRE forecasting a return to these levels by the third quarter of 2024. As of last year, foot traffic had already recovered to 81% of 2019 figures in 10 key retail locations. However, the retail landscape faces challenges due to increased rents, which have risen by 9% in the Americas and 5.8% globally since 2021. This has led to record-low space availability and high rental costs, prompting retailers to explore innovative growth strategies and alternative locations with lower rents and fewer operational constraints.

Retailers are adapting by expanding into smaller, alternative locations to facilitate brand growth and enhance convenience for digital transactions. The importance of physical stores in driving digital sales remains significant; the International Council of Shopping Centers (ICSC) noted that opening a physical store can boost a brand's online sales by nearly 7%, whereas closing one might decrease them by 11.5%. Moreover, the interplay between online and offline sales channels continues to be crucial, with physical stores accounting for 78% of retail growth in 2022, a significant increase from 46% in 2019.

Reports of Street Retail’s Demise Are Greatly Exaggerated

PRINTABLE VERSION HERE

IADS recently held a meeting on the Cosmetics & Beauty sector. Based on market research, NellyRodi and The Style Pulse presented the most innovative brands from different segments in cosmetics and beauty including skincare, makeup, haircare, fragrances, and more.

Check out our selection of these brands and the pictures by clicking the button below!

SKINCARE

IPSUM ALII

IPSUM ALII uses scientifically proven ingredients, infused with the ancient wisdom of Kampo medicinal herbs, associated with their anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties, to restore skin to its equilibrium state.

Check out the IPSUM ALII website here

CHECK OUT IPSUM ALII's INSTAGRAM

MIMÉTIQUE

Mimétique is a skincare brand that targets knowledgeable consumers with scientifically-backed, education-focused products. They offer effective skincare solutions formulated with active ingredients that are kind to the skin and environmentally sustainable, using green chemistry and biotechnology in their French-made products.

Check out the MIMÉTIQUE website here

check out the MIMÉTIQUE instagram here

MTMLABO

MTMLABO is a skincare brand that offers custom-blended products using a unique library of botanical extracts. For over 30 years, the company has specialized in personalizing skincare to match individual needs and skin types, promoting natural beauty and self-acceptance.

Check out the MTMLABO website here

check out the MTMLABO instagram here

TALM

Talm is a skincare brand designed for women during pregnancy, postpartum, and breastfeeding, emphasizing safety, effectiveness, and beauty. Founded by Kenza Keller, the products are organic, vegan, and environmentally friendly, made in France, and include specialized prenatal and postpartum massages to enhance maternal well-being.

Check out the TALM website here

Check out the TALM instagram here

MEGABABE

Megababe is a body care brand founded to address common yet often overlooked issues like thigh chafing, underboob sweat, and body odor. Focused on creating clean, vegan, and appealing products, Megababe aims to tackle "taboo" body topics, helping people feel more comfortable and confident in their own skin.

check out the megababe website here 

check out the megababe instagram here 

MAKEUP

OBAYATY

Obayaty is a men's beauty brand that combines luxury, wellness, and innovation to promote self-care and self-expression. Using sustainable, consciously sourced materials and potent formulas, Obayaty offers a multipurpose collection that encourages male beauty and inclusivity, while striving for harmony with the community and the planet.

Check out the OBAYATY Website Here 

check out the OBAYATY instagram here

FLORASIS

Florasis is a beauty brand that combines traditional Chinese beauty rituals with modern technology, offering products that blend makeup and skincare. Their line emphasizes nourishing floral essences, celebrating the legacy of ancient craftsmanship while promoting inner health and outer beauty.

check out the Florasis website here 

check out the Florasis instagram here

GOOD WEIRD

Good Weird is a beauty brand that champions inclusivity and exploration in the beauty aisle. Emphasizing ease and versatility, their multipurpose products are designed for every gender, skill level, skin tone, and type, encouraging everyone to express their individuality. Good Weird is about looking good, feeling better, and embracing the unique in each of us.

check out the good weird website here 

check out the good weird instagram here

FARA HOMIDI

Fara Homidi embodies "Slow Beauty" with high-performance, cruelty-free cosmetics that prioritize quality and environmental responsibility. The brand uses sustainable materials for packaging and offers refill options, emphasizing a luxurious, eco-conscious approach to beauty.

checkout the fara homidi website here 

checkout the fara homidi instagram here 

Printable version here

Have you heard about Taylor Swift, a singer with a global impact?

Last year, NYU announced a class based on her. In March and November 2023, Stanford and Harvard respectively announced they would do the same. Swift holds the record for most songs to ever chart on the US Billboard Hot 100 (188 songs), and in fall 2022 she became the first artist to own the entire Top 10 simultaneously. Finally, Taylor Swift’s 2023 “Eras Tour” is the first tour to gross $1 billion, surpassing Elton John (the previous record holder with $939 million for his “Farewell Yellow Brick Road” tour).

In one way or another, Taylor Swift has amazed the world with her music, persona and business skills for over a decade. Sparked by this buzz, the IADS took a look at this phenomenon to figure out how exactly this popstar branded herself and her music and how she became a master in influence. Her highly engaged community of fans is interesting to look into to understand how emotion is a key factor in enhancing loyalty.

Co-creation, the value of the middleman

Is control everything? 

One of the most notable copyright cases in the music industry happened when Taylor Swift tried to purchase her ‘masters’ (the original recordings of her songs) in an attempt to control her music. The story is that after leaving her former record label where she recorded her first six albums, Swift found out that her manager had acquired her ‘masters’, preventing her from using her own music. This is when she decided to re-record her albums. Dubbed “Taylor’s versions”, they instantly acquired a higher value than the original recordings. Compared to the original ones, the new versions resulted in +43% in streaming and +4512% in album sales.

In a way, Taylor Swift's copyright case could be compared to a brand reclaiming control ownership and trying to increase its margin by going direct-to-consumer hence skipping the multi-brand retailer. This has been a fantasy that DNVBs like Glossier thought they could fulfil before realising that 1) they needed physical outlets to show their products and increase their customer reach, and 2) multi-brand retailers were well equipped to offer them this physical outlet. In the case of Glossier, they opened (and closed) a few free-standing stores and ended up signing a deal with Sephora in the US and Canada. For smaller DNVBs, engaging with a multi-brand retailer is also a way to test the waters before going brick-and-mortar. So just any brand can pretend to be the Taylor Swift of its category.

Convenience and relevance 

In their defence, it is worth reminding that, as a middleman, department stores also have a large and diverse range of merchandise and are located in city centres most of the time. As a result, to be efficient with their time and resources, it could be a more rational decision for the customer to shop at their facilities rather than at a single retailer. Convenience is an important factor in the customer journey that can greatly influence the purchasing option. On top of customer ease, department stores offer other significant advantages. As they attract different types of customers, they often have a superior market knowledge compared to a single brand. Adding a middleman into the sales process is also in the interest of the brand, as they can gain insights into customer behaviour and the performance of competing businesses. This is increasingly the case thanks to the retail media growing business (see our latest white paper on the topic). Also, when it comes to fashion or lifestyle brands, they can gain more flare and coolness by being displayed and mixed with other labels. And above all, department stores assume most of the market risk.

The case of the collaboration between Beyonce and Flannels 

Retailers are evolving from being a pure marketplace to experience hubs or even cultural centres as mentioned in a previous IADS Exclusive. In that regard, department stores are and have always been cultural stakeholders and their cultural footprint is ever-present. Luxury brands are also embracing the cultural aspect of physical retail with the emerging trend of mega flagships such as the Dior one in Paris.

In the world of department stores, Flannels is currently rethinking the role of its London flagship store. They opened a new space dubbed Flannels X. Rather than a space designed to sell products, it is meant to become an ever-evolving cultural playground of pop-ups, gigs and exhibitions for cultural creators to exchange and broadcast ideas. On the occasion of Beyoncé’s tour coming to London in May 2023, Flannels X had a pop-up store showing the Beyoncé x Balmain couture collection for the first time, and also selling merchandise from Beyonce’s Renaissance World Tour. While positioning the store at the intersection of luxury and pop culture to offer more experiences, this initiative helps Flannels create a community of younger engaged customers able to develop influence. It also demonstrates the relevance of department stores when it comes to collaborating with artists or brands: in the case of Beyoncé, Flannels offers her a convenient outlet she wouldn’t have otherwise. And in the case of brands, department stores remain customer magnets.

Developing influence: the power of a community

Building a community  

Beyonce has the BeyHive and Taylor Swift has her Swifties. They analyse her social media posts, lyrics, and visuals and try to predict the artist’s next move. This type of superfans is crucial to the success of the artist: they are the people who buy everything from vinyl records to merchandising, collect memorabilia, spend hours streaming the newly dropped music on every platform possible, and get the most expensive ticket package at every tour. But there’s more.

In 2007, researchers Duncan Watts and Peter Dobbs interrogated influence as a phenomenon. Their work revealed that influence is not driven by individuals but by a critical mass of easily influenced individuals. In fact, their research suggests that the Beyoncés and Taylor Swifts of the world are only modestly more influential than average individuals. This may sound counter-intuitive, but the spread of ideas and behaviours depends less on the person who starts them, and more on how susceptible the group is to what is being spread. It would be irrelevant to deny Taylor Swift’s influence though, but her true influence is on the Swifties, who in turn influence their friends, their other connections and beyond. In other words, Swift influence power should be attributed to her ability to foster a community. Rather than trying to reach out to everyone, it’s more effective to speak to superfans.

Rewarding the superfans 

First, Taylor Swift rewards her super fans by reposting or commenting on their posts. But the superfans are granted more. They can receive an invitation to secret sessions which are small and intimate gatherings in Swift’s home, in which she hosts previews of her new albums. While it seems Taylor Swift has its own tier-based loyalty programme, it might be difficult for retailers to offer a similar kind of reward as it goes through a true form of intimacy. However, DNVBs such as Glossier succeeded in establishing direct lines of communication with their customers through their websites, social media, etc, which foster a strong sense of community and trust. Superfan customers feel heard and valued as if they were truly part of the brand's adventure and narrative. But they (the VICs and VVICs) need to be rewarded in an emotional way that could compare to what Swift is doing with her secret sessions. Retailers have taken notes.

Loyalty programmes: rewarding through emotion

The case of Sephora 

A recent example of rewarding VICs comes from Sephora. When reopening their Paris Champs-Elysées store in October 2023, they gave privileged access to some of their best customers, even before the stars flooded the opening party. Over the past decade, Sephora has become a champion in leveraging the emotional drivers of loyalty. Research has found that almost 75% of what drives customer engagement and loyalty are emotional perks. Sephora believes emotional rewards are the new currency of loyalty. Sure, the right balance of transactional and emotional is needed, but Sephora’s Beauty Insider programme leans toward the emotional side, especially since 2017 when they launched the Beauty Insider Community for their superfans. It was designed to be an opportunity for beauty addicts (spending more than $1000 per year) to come together, ask questions, comment on products and post beauty looks. It is also a great way to get product recommendations, not just from Sephora but from the community itself. It’s a real-time, real-talk forum that has become a great resource for the customers and for the retailer to collect precious data.

Other examples from the industry 

When inviting a handful of their best customers to their runway shows, luxury brands master the emotional part of loyalty. With competition being increasingly fierce, some of them upped the ante by inviting their superfans (their VVICs) to their showrooms. It is a way to offer access to a form of ‘behind the scenes’, but mostly they can choose the items they want months ahead of their official in-store release. Other luxury brands understand the power lying in rewards based on human interaction. For example, Brunello Cuccinelli himself meets and spends time with the top brand VICs.

During the IADS Operations Meeting dedicated to Chief Customer Officers, members talked about customers' rising expectations for non-tangible benefits. In that regard, The Mall increases the benefits related to status such as lounge access, free parking, pre-sales and special seats for events. To create an emotional bond, El Palacio de Hierro offers a bottle of wine or a meal at one of their restaurants for their best customers' birthdays. On its side, Boyner considers offering airport fast-track for their top-tier customers. They also found out that people ask for digital subscriptions like Spotify premium: the cost is low and appreciation is high.

Other examples are interesting to consider in the reward economy. Chewy (the US pet brand) sends its best pet owner customers free, personalised portraits of their cats and dogs. Moreover, when a customer loses their pet, Chewy sends a letter of condolence. This human touch is priceless for the ones receiving the letter and a guarantee those customers will be returning to Chewy as soon as they get a new pet. Moreover, by rewarding their best customers, brands and retailers generate meaningful word of mouth and earn media value. The fans who attend one of Swift’s secret sessions will tell everyone they know about it for years. The customer who gets an unexpected pet portrait from Chewy will share it on social media and offer Chewy free marketing.

Conclusion

The remarkable success of Taylor Swift offers insights for the retail industry, highlighting the power of community and emotional engagement in fostering customer loyalty. Swift's ability to build a dedicated community of fans, the Swifties, is a lesson in developing brand loyalty. Retailers can learn from this by developing their own communities and rewarding their most loyal customers, as exemplified by Sephora's Beauty Insider programme, which balances transactional and emotional rewards to foster a strong customer connection. In addition, the emotional aspect of customer rewards, a key component of Swift's success, is crucial. Retailers can create a lasting impact by offering unique experiences and personalised gestures that resonate emotionally with customers, much like Swift's secret sessions or Chewy's personalised pet portraits. Besides, in the digitalised world we are living in, boundaries between categories tend to fade away. It is an opportunity to learn from other industries as they share the same customer base as retailers. They might have different practices which can be inspiring for department stores.

Credits: IADS (Christine Montard)

Printable version here

The future of department stores has become a topic that experts and media have expressed their views on many times, predicting the end of the model. While the so-called “retail apocalypse” didn’t happen, the retail landscape is indeed changing with a long list of mid-range store chains collapsing everywhere in the world and department stores evolving their model. With COVID-19, they showed agility to reinvent themselves by developing online capabilities overnight, updating their product offer and including more experiences and services to differentiate from the competition.

However, the transformation is not over yet. We are seeing an increase in the number of department stores resembling malls, favouring luxury over the idea of a ‘department store for all’. Conversely, branded retailers are increasingly resembling department stores. In that regard and following a premiumization strategy, Zara's most recent stores are taking cues from the department store playbook. Also, Marks & Spencer has emerged as a winner in the UK retail landscape.

Is that a natural evolution from both sides? Now that branded retailers are taking on the department stores’ codes, what’s in for department stores themselves? Are there any fundamental risks if they lose their factor of differentiation, or is it just a not-so-important question of display and presentation? Some department store companies have dropped the traditional way of presenting products by section and opted for a very immersive approach, becoming very large concept stores in the process. Is the future approach of department stores to merge customer journeys into innovative store concepts, to remain destinations for customers and differentiate from copycats who contribute to commodifying their once-typical approach?

A progressive evolution towards a luxury mall experience on some department stores’ floors…

Traditionally, department stores have been regarded as stores selling luxury in one form or another (either via their ‘look & feel’ or simply with the products and services offered). Take Galeries Lafayette in Paris: they are expanding the luxury footprint on the ground floor, with leading leather goods brands such as Loewe, Gucci and Balenciaga having bigger shop-in-shops. Considering their remarkable size, they can increasingly be compared to these brands’ free-standing stores. Also, Chanel and Louis Vuitton are growing their presence on the first floor, only further emphasizing the luxury mall feeling. Finally, with brands like Rabanne, Jacquemus, Carven, Marni, Jil Sander and Acne Studios, more affordable luxury fashion is also expanding with larger shop-in-shops on the second floor (compared to their previous locations on the first floor). Expanding luxury on the second floor is unprecedented as it was previously only dedicated to premium brands such as Sandro and Maje. In Copenhagen, Illum has Celine, Prada and Balenciaga shop-in-shops that are both accessible from the street and the department store's ground floor, transforming them into real free-standing stores. This set-up with double access to boutiques is now visible in every part of the world, from KaDeWe in Berlin to Beymen’s Zorlu location in Istanbul, or The Mall Group EmQuartier in Thailand.

Another example is Harrods, in London, which relentlessly ups the ante with luxurious shop-in-shops. The first floor is dedicated to luxury RTW and has truly become a mall. The plan also includes transforming the affordable luxury and contemporary fashion floor in the same way. Luxury fashion is undeniably ingrained in the DNA of department stores, so it's only natural for them to prioritize it. But one can wonder if the flare of those stores is still there; from a customer’s perspective, why shop at Harrods when you could have the flagship store experience a few blocks away? In the past, department stores allowed customers intimidated by luxury flagships to have access to luxury products. Now, in the new-generation Harrods, such clients may not feel as comfortable shopping there following the upgrade.

But to what extent is that a deliberate strategy? Luxury brands are increasingly pressurizing department stores to provide an experience in their locations on par with what brands are now able to display in their own, highly sophisticated, experiential, free-standing stores. In case department stores are not able, or willing, to accept such requests (which also often come with new demands in terms of financial arrangements), such brands do not hesitate to leave, putting the department store’s ability to regroup a compelling and aspirational offer in one place at risk.

…while, at the same time, branded retailers take on their codes

In the UK, Marks & Spencer is an interesting breed achieving growth while others are struggling. With the opening of 9 new stores in November 2023, they are in the middle of a massive store rotation and optimization programme aiming to transition from 247 stores to 180 higher quality, higher productivity, full-line stores, while maintaining their competitive advantage with the right locations. Also, M&S focuses on and streamlines its product range and achieves digital transformation, resulting in strong financial performance and increased sales. M&S's CEO, Stuart Machin, emphasized going back to the company's foundations of providing quality products at the best price and putting the customer at the heart of everything they do. Marks & Spencer gives a series of reasons to pay a visit:

• The onboarding of third-party brands: they bought out Jaeger (after its collapse) to revive its fashion department and include more beauty brands (they now sell 47 labels accounting for 40% of the beauty sales).
• In Leeds, which is their “best store yet” according to the CEO, the 9,000 square metre surface (formerly a Debenhams store) houses a supermarket, a fresh market-style food hall, a flower shop, a spacious clothing, home and beauty department, and a 164-seat café.
• A product offer tailored to local needs.
• Fun sensorial attractions to emphasize the experiential feeling, with cow sounds in milk aisles and rooster sounds in the egg areas.
• Events with daily M&S product testing such as alcohol-free wines or specialty coffee.

It is telling that M&S’s CEO has vowed to open “better, bigger” stores in former Debenhams locations than in the past, as it increasingly blurs the once very clear boundary between them and middle-class department stores selling fashion, home and beauty.

The case of fast-fashion operator Zara also raises a series of questions, as it has consistently challenged the boundaries between their offer, and, for a long time, luxury brand codes. After all, they were among the first ones to present coherent and structured stories in their windows at a moment when then old-school luxury houses were still simply showing products to passers-by. In the same perspective, they muscled up the notion of visual merchandising, as the concept of having an enticing store at each visit is part of their business model. Luxury brands and department stores noticed and learned along the way.

Fast fashion’s second transformative wave is now about associating the qualities once solely linked with department stores and making them the norm. Fast fashion seems to have appropriated them in a very convincing way: branded retail stores now look like department stores, and should their logo be removed, the illusion would be perfect.

For example, Zara in Battersea Power Station in London or in Champs-Elysées in Paris: both in terms of categories and set-up, they look like mini department stores. The new Zara concept is described as a stroll through different sophisticated atmospheres. The use of different upgraded materials and contrasting shades helps to delimit the spaces and product lines. Accessories and shoes now have their own section with a comfortable seating area and single shoes displayed on shelves, as in any department store. Lingerie is displayed in a specific cocoon-like area. While the Champs-Elysées store (2,700 square meters) only offers men's and women's RTW and accessories, the Battersea Power Station store is even more impressive. Spanning 4,500 square meters, it is the home of all product categories developed by Zara: men’s and women’s RTW and accessories, but also kids, beauty and an impressive Zara Home shop-in-shop. The result is quite stunning and extremely elevated for a fast fashion brand. Also, the customer journey is easier and more efficient thanks to the embedded RFID technology: Zara offers self-checkout options, but also faster access to fitting rooms as the counting of items is automated in real-time. Besides, customers can book their fitting room in advance to avoid waiting in line. Finally, as the stores have different departments and are getting bigger, there is a need for more directions: QR codes help customers locate the different sections on a map.

As a consequence, Zara’s stores are part of the process helping the brand to elevate itself in terms of customer perception, without raising its prices, which is a strong competitive advantage in a moment when new business models (Shein, Temu) are rising fast1. In the process, one could feel confused: remove the Zara sign in Battersea, and it would be easy to feel in a U.S. department store for instance, thanks to the quality of execution and store zoning. In a similar manner, the new Massimo Dutti store in Paris Champs-Elysées would not look too foreign to the usual men’s department store section anywhere in the world, as IADS’ partner Newstores reported last December.

But if branded retail smells, looks and tastes like good old department stores, what should actual department stores do to remain ahead of the race?

In 2024, what is a department store anyway?

To stay relevant, make a difference from copycats and aside from their price point, it is generally agreed that department stores should make sure to propose the following:

• Show tradition, authenticity and roots, but not too much to avoid looking old and stuffy
• Develop experiences, which means the store should be interesting enough to be worth the trip
• Emphasize novelty, spectacle and events, which will depend on where the store is located and whom it addresses
• Include more hospitality, an increasing part of the shopping experience
• Increase services, be it human or otherwise linked with understanding
• Guaranty variety in the product, brand and category offer
• And make sure the overall environment will make lingering worthwhile.

While most of these key points are ticked by iconic department stores such as Selfridges, Galeries Lafayette and KaDeWe, good examples of department stores not looking like department stores, but actually interesting destinations, could be Liberty in London, Le Bon Marché in Paris, Bergdorf Goodman in New York, or Jelmoli in Zurich. The catch? All these department stores are destinations because they only have one store. But what are the options for department store companies with more than one flagship store? 2 options seem to rise from the analysis of the market:

• Become Harrods, Liberty or Selfridges. Retailers now know they don’t need a store everywhere. Fewer but better stores with a deeper rather than broader assortment and a high level of service could be a solution. The extreme is of course for a chain to shrink to one door only, lose scale effect and negotiation power, and end up being dependent on external factors which become critical from merely influential in the past (the reasons of the demise of Barney’s in New York in 2020 are, in the end, purely linked to their inability to generate scale effect and, therefore, remain dependent on lease conditions. Jelmoli in Switzerland is the same).
• Become John Lewis (especially the Oxford Street store) or Frasers. This means going wide and increasing the entry-level appeal.  The issue is that the days of “everything under one roof” and “a bit of everything for everybody” are not anymore a working recipe for physical retail now that companies like Amazon do that very well online.

So, what should we learn from the fact that department stores have such a footprint that they are now imitated by large single-brand retailers, leaving them in a position of not being able to pivot unless they lose their most critical factor, their bargaining power thanks to their scale? Does this mean that the only future of department stores is to become great again by becoming a single destination, to the point of disappearing because this is the nature of any business based on trends?

Some markets have generated the conditions for the appearance of new concepts and business models. In China, department stores such as SKP-S and K11, or EmQuartier in Bangkok, Thailand, are interesting because they keep the purpose of a department store (curate an interesting offer for a curious customer and make sure the location is attractive and enticing, in one coherent and unified concept) but also unbundle its components at the same time. In SKP-S, K11 or EmQuartier, product offer is not organized by department, but by customer journey. In addition, the whole store displays such a strong concept (otherworldly at SKP-S, arty in K11 and entertaining in EmQuartier) that it becomes a destination per se, just like Galeries Lafayette Haussmann with the cupola, Harrods with the Egyptian staircase, or the atrium at Saks Fifth Avenue in New York), but with a je-ne-sais-quoi based on something else than purely architectural details. In addition, these concepts are created with the ambition to bring their specificities to various locations, not to base their uniqueness on one single, iconic location.

For anyone familiar with the evolution of fashion retail in the last 50 years, this means that large department store companies are putting the notion of concept store on steroids, by expanding this approach on a much larger scale (both in terms of single store surface and number of stores), mixed with the capability of department store companies to identify, curate and enhance interesting new trends and brands, but this time organized by customer journey and profile, and not anymore by section. In other words, any customer can have a different high-octane experience in these stores, at each visit.

Conclusion: Department stores have embedded their own reinvention in themselves since the beginning

It is no secret that department store companies have managed to adapt to many retail disruptions in the past, from the appearance of malls and commercial centres in cities’ peripherical zones, to discounters, hypermarkets, speciality chains, e-commerce and DTC brands. As they have managed to do so until now, they will probably manage to find a solution to this seemingly strange issue: how to remain special when companies from other industries do everything possible to look like them?

As SKP-S, K11 and EmQuartier show, it is possible to remain special while also being attractive to both customers and brands (who are not tempted to think that these department stores are increasingly becoming commoditized by new players). However, heritage companies such as Galeries Lafayette, El Palacio de Hierro or Breuninger do not have the luxury to close their stores and rebuild them in a new manner (even though this is what Breuninger is doing now that it has acquired the former Konen department store in Munich).

And yet, this is with this reinvention in mind that new initiatives should be seen, from the increase of high-end restaurants in Harrods (to revamp the experience just like what K11 is doing) to the Wellness Galerie in Galeries Lafayette (mixing retail and paid experiences like in SKP-S) or the way new El Palacio de Hierro stores are designed (in terms of seamless customer journey, independently of brands or business models, just like in EmQuartier).

Everyone in the industry knows that status-quo is not a viable strategy for survival. While chain stores and branded retail are progressively adopting old-world department store codes to gain credibility and luxury perception, department stores are, on their side, reviewing what they bring to a customer who has also changed in recent years. Old recipes will not work for new generations. This is one of the reasons why many IADS department store members have already started working on reviewing their approach to the customer journey, to imagine how they can present what they have to offer to new customers, accustomed to purchasing differently compared to their parents.

Credits: IADS (Christine Montard)

What: Visa reviews the situation in Europe to understand if there is light at the end of the tunnel.

Why it is important: To make a long story short, the answer is “yes, maybe”.

The economic landscape of 2024 shows signs of a potential turnaround following a sluggish start, particularly in Europe. Despite varying economic performance across countries, with the U.K. and Germany experiencing recessions and Spain showing relative strength, there is a general easing of inflation and a resilience in labor markets across the region. Central banks are cautiously optimistic, adjusting their inflation forecasts and tempering expectations for immediate rate cuts.

Consumer spending in Europe remains subdued but is expected to gain momentum as real incomes improve and inflation pressures subside. According to Visa’s regional Spending Momentum Index, consumer spending growth is evident, though Italy has seen a stagnation. Consumer confidence has reached a two-year high, supporting forecasts of continued spending increases throughout the year.

Inflation in the Eurozone is on a disinflationary path, with significant reductions from a peak of 10.6% to 2.4% by March. Some nations, including Italy, Ireland, and Finland, have seen inflation rates dip below the European Central Bank's target of 2%. Core inflation is also decreasing, projected to stabilize at 2% by the end of the year, fostering expectations for a rate cut by late spring or summer.

Europe: is a turnaround coming soon?

What: In the US, the extreme storm season has left its mark on spending power and retail.

Why it is important: Expect this kind of impact to generalize accross the board.

In April, Visa's U.S. Spending Momentum Index (SMI) saw a significant drop of 4.8 points month-over-month, settling at 93.8, which is below the critical 100-point mark indicating broad-based consumer spending expansion. This decline marks a departure from two months of robust growth and was influenced heavily by severe weather conditions, including an unusual spike in tornado activity, with 300 recorded tornadoes making it the second highest for any April on record. The adverse weather substantially reduced consumer mobility, directly impacting spending habits across all categories.

Economic factors also played a role in this spending slowdown. Job growth in April decreased with only 175,000 new jobs added, a notable reduction from March's 315,000. Wage increases also slowed, with nominal gains rising by just 0.2 percent compared to 0.4 percent in the previous month. Additionally, a significant increase in gas prices, which rose 5.4 percent month-over-month and 17 percent since the year's start, further strained consumer budgets. This financial pressure led to cutbacks in essential spending, such as groceries, significantly impacting the non-discretionary SMI.

The culmination of slower job and wage growth, along with rising energy costs and severe weather, contributed to a sharp decline in consumer confidence, reaching a 21-month low in April. This decline in confidence likely spurred consumers to reduce discretionary spending, further driving down the discretionary SMI.

In the US, extreme weather now has a visible impact on retail